Insurance in Port Saint Lucie, FL

Where unbeatable service meets great, low rates!

At McGarr Insurance, we empower you to get the coverage you need to protect your family and your assets at a price you can afford.

Get a Quote Now


Excellent Service

We pride ourselves on providing an unbeatable level of customer service, professionalism, communication, and courtesy.

We Listen

Each customer’s needs are different, and we listen to understand how we can best serve your specific insurance needs.

Convenient Location

Our office is conveniently located at 493 SW Port St. Lucie Boulevard, in the heart of beautiful Port Saint Lucie, Florida.

Auto Insurance

Need a quote on auto insurance? Give us a call today. We’d like to help.

Homeowners Insurance

We offer great home policies with highly-rated carriers. Call to learn more.

parents and kid on a dock

Life Insurance

Have you ever thought about protecting your most important asset – your life? Ask us how much life insurance your family may need if you were to pass away suddenly.

We are SO pleased to have Matt McGarr taking care of our insurance for house, flood, and auto coverage. Matt responds immediately to any questions, etc. we may have. Matt also does an excellent job in researching all of the options and finds the best fit for us, as well as the best price. Matt is professional, courteous, reliable and very efficient! We highly recommend Matt to help you with your insurance needs.

–Diana. A


We are experienced and fully licensed insurance agents.

Let our experience work for you as we find great policies that fit your needs, and at prices that fit your budget.

Message Us

We are a local business you can depend on for quality and service.

Call Us

(772) 335-0915

Your Local Insurance Partner

Call or visit us today for a free quote.